Has the Hiring Process Gotten Out of Hand?

I certainly think so. 

Having hired over 13,000 people in the past 10 years, I will tell you that the current requirements to hire a new employee have become daunting.  I am beginning to think that a large portion of the unemployment rate is self inflicted.  Each year, we are finding more ways to screen out candidates instead of finding ways to include or grow good talent.  Here is listing of just a few of the hiring requirements that our members have had to comply with in order to be considered for employment.

  • – Resume submittal into an applicant tracking system
  • – Telephone interview
  • – Hiring Assessment (Six assessments is the highest number that I have heard of thus far.)
  • – IQ test (Yes, you read correctly.)
  • – Personal interviews (11 are the highest so far)
  • – Group interview (the largest panel has been 12 members)
  • – Requirement to submit a 5 minute, self-developed video of why you are qualified for the position.
  • – 15 minute stand-up presentation including a PowerPoint presentation.
  • – Submittal of a marketing or territory sales plan
  • – Submittal of your latest W-2
  • – Confidentially agreement and non-compete agreement
  • – Filling out an Application for Employment
  • – Drug and background check
  • – I-9 identification including 2 pieces of government issued ID or passport.

At any point in the hiring process, someone involved in the evaluation can say “no”.  “No” is a safe answer.  There is little risk in saying “no”.  Saying “yes” commits you to the decision and to the success of the candidate.  I’ll take the risk.  Making a new hire successful is a responsibility that I accept.

Let’s trim down the list and say “yes” more often. 

What do you think?

Ken Lazar

This entry was posted in Job Search, Recruiter, Recruiter Questions, Recruiting 102, Recruiting Thoughts, Sourcing and tagged , , , , , by Ken Lazar. Bookmark the permalink.

About Ken Lazar

Ken Lazar is a staffing services professional and Managing Director for Experis Engineering. His team places high quality talent in the Engineering, Scientific, other business professional fields. During his career Ken has put over 12,000 people to work. In 2006, Ken founded the Scioto Ridge Job Networking Group which has become the largest faith-based job networking group in Central Ohio. As a result of his work with Scioto Ridge, Ken founded the Professional Career Development Network, Inc, a non-profit organization, to help fund the cost of continuing education, training and certification of experienced professionals in job transition. A graduate in Industrial Engineering from Kettering University and Master of Science in Industrial Administration from the Krannert Business School at Purdue University, Ken and his wife, Nancy, reside in Hilliard, Ohio. Ken is an avid golfer, runner and photographer and owns the best dog on the planet. Professional Organization Affiliations - Human Resources Association of Central Ohio, Ohio Association of Executive Search Professionals, National Association of Personnel Services, National Association of Workforce Development Professionals, Columbus Metropolitan Club, Columbus Chamber of Commerce, Tech Columbus, Frank Lloyd Wright Foundation, ASPCA, United States Golf Association Public Speaking - Ohio Association of Executive Search Professionals, “The Near Term US Employment Outlook” "The Human Age" - JFS, "12 Things You Can Do Right Now to Take 60 Days Off Your Job Search" - 2011 Small Business Forum & Leadership Awards, "The Human Age" - TechColumbus, Dublin Entrepreneurial Center, “Researching Contacts and Companies” - Career Management Alliance Conference, New Orleans, “The Role of Job Networking Groups in the Community.” - Execunet and the American Marketing Association, “Researching Contacts and Companies.” - The Council for Supply Chain Management Professionals “The 2010 Employment Outlook” Media and Webinars - CBS affiliate WBNS 10TV News, “Survival Source Job Alert”. - Ohio New Network “Inviting Conversations”. - FOX News, WTTE-TV28, “Good Day Columbus”. - CareerBoard Webinar, ”Janice Worthington, Ask the Expert”. - Right Management National Job Strategy Webinar. - Columbus Business First, “A Conversation with Ken Lazar”. - Sunny95, 94.5 fm, “Inviting Conversations”. .